Archive for the ‘South China Sea’ Category

Post

China plays a dangerous game.

In International Relations,Politics,South China Sea,The Rise of China on May 11, 2012 by The Nutbox

China is encouraging calls to go to war with the Philippines.

Analysts and students of China’s domestic politics are now becoming unanimous in observing that the heated rhetoric coming from Beijing regarding its stand-off with Manila over the Scarborough Shoal is a ploy to divert the country’s attention away from the Bo Xilai and Chen Guangcheng scandals that have rocked the Communist Party (CCP). Apparently, the party brass deem that this diversion is vital to stabilize the political situation in the midst of the on-going delicate baton-passing between President Hu Jintao and Vice President Xi Jinping.

The CCP has long used nationalism, along with economic gains, as a pillar to support its legitimacy in the eyes of the Chinese people, as well as to distract them from its domestic political abuses. This explains why Beijing is encouraging its state-run news agencies to beat the nationalist drums at the Philippines’ expense, with several newspapers seriously advocating war with Manila. According to our friends in Beijing, the ploy has succeeded; the Scarborough stand-off is now the talk of the town, and the Bo Xilai and Chen Guangcheng cases are now old news.

Read More »

Post

Clinton’s ‘hands-off’ declaration is not an abandonment of the Philippines.

In International Relations,Philippine Politics,Politics,South China Sea,The Rise of China on May 2, 2012 by The Nutbox

Top Filipino and American security and foreign policy officials meet in Washington yesterday for the Ministerial Dialogue of the US-Philippine alliance.

Some lawmakers in Manila are upset with American Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s declaration that the United States does not take sides in the territorial disputes in the South China Sea. They should know, however, that a declaration of American neutrality in terms of the competing claims in the area is in fact more beneficial to the Philippines.

The American position on the Scarborough crisis, as articulated by Secretary Clinton in yesterday’s Philippine-American ministerial dialogue in Washinton, is actually more nuanced than the supposed neutrality that these lawmakers—and the Daily Tribune— are trying to paint. While Washington does not take sides on sovereignty issues; it has declared that it is against the threat or the use of force, and is in favor of a multilateral approach, in solving the Scarborough crisis. It has also reiterated that it will honor its obligations under the Mutual Defense Treaty (MDT) and that it will commit itself to building a “minimum credible defense posture” for the Philippines.

Read More »

Post

Manila should try to understand how Beijing works, too.

In International Relations,Philippine Politics,Politics,South China Sea,The Rise of China on April 27, 2012 by The Nutbox

The Philippines holds its ground amidst Chinese bullying.

When China prevented the Philippines from apprehending illegal Chinese poachers caught pilfering endangered marine life in the Scarborough Shoal— in clear violation of Philippine and international laws— it probably thought that the militarily-weak Philippines would meekly submit and call it a day. But as an American expert on Asian affairs said, Beijing has clearly underestimated Manila’s resolve.

For sixteen days now, Philippine and Chinese vessels are in a stand-off in the Scarborough, and neither side is showing signs of blinking. The military power asymmetry between the two sides is beyond obvious. China has an overwhelming advantage. The Philippines, however, knows how to play its cards.

Read More »

Post

Boldest stance ever.

In International Relations,Philippine Politics,Politics,South China Sea,The ASEAN,The Rise of China on July 30, 2011 by The Nutbox

Aquino: What is ours is ours.

“Our message to the world is clear: What is ours is ours,” says President Benigno S. Aquino in his annual State of the Nation Address in Congress last Monday. “Setting foot on Recto Bank is no different from setting foot on Recto Avenue.”

Recto Bank is the Filipino term for Reeds Bank, which is located between the Spratlys and Palawan, and within the country’s 300 nautical mile Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). Recto Avenue, on the other hand, is a street in Manila that leads to the presidential palace

This has to be the boldest stance ever taken by a Philippine president on the disputes in the West Philippine Sea (Manila’s term for the South China Sea). Marcos, although he strengthened the Philippine claim on the Spratlys by putting up an airstrip and some garrisons on several islets there, never lifted a finger when the Vietnamese grabbed one of the Philippine-held island there in the 1970s. Ramos rallied the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) against Chinese military build-up on Mischief Reef, but in the end, despite singing an Elvis Presley duet with Chinese President Jiang Zemin, he couldn’t do anything about China’s island-grab. Arroyo, of course, cozied up to China by coming up with a Joint Marine Seismic Undertaking (JMSU)— Manila’s bungle, according to Barry Wain—apparently in exchange for Chinese loans that, unlike Japanese and European loans, had little or no safety nets against graft and corruption.

Read More »

Post

Will the US come to the Philippines’ aid in the Spratlys?

In International Relations,Philippine Politics,Politics,South China Sea,The ASEAN,The Rise of China on June 21, 2011 by The Nutbox

The mutual defense treaty between the Philippines and the United States has no 'automatic retaliation' clause.

Japan has a similar question: In case of an attack on Tokyo, would the Americans risk Los Angeles to retaliate? If Japan feels insecure and starts transforming itself from a pacifist to a “normal” country, the suspicious Koreans and Chinese would respond in a manner that could threaten regional stability. This is why the Americans would always go out of their way to reassure the Japanese in the strongest possible terms. When tensions broke out between Beijing and Tokyo last year over a row in the disputed Senkaku Island, for instance, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton herself categorically pointed out that the disputed island fall under the Mutual Defense Treaty (MDT) between Tokyo and Washington.

Read More »

Post

China’s credible challenge.

In International Relations,South China Sea,The Rise of China on August 31, 2010 by The Nutbox

Just as China was protesting the draping of the Philippine flag on the coffin of Rolando Mendoza, the cop-turned-terrorist who murdered eight Hong Kong nationals in Manila last Monday, its submarines were returning home from a successful mission to plant a Chinese flag beneath the South China Sea. It was the latest act of renewed Chinese assertiveness in the disputed region and a demonstration of China’s underwater capabilities.

Of course, the flag-planting doesn’t give the Chinese what they don’t already have with regards to their claims to the South China Sea. It’s not the first time in recent years that China demonstrated unilateral assertiveness either. But the stunt was significant because it was a rebuke to the United States, which has recently weighed in on the dispute.

Read More »

Post

Philippine Baselines Bill: The bigger picture.

In International Relations,Philippine Politics,Politics,South China Sea on March 5, 2009 by The Nutbox

base

Much is being said about the Philippine Baselines Bill, especially now that it has been approved by a bicameral committee of Congress.  Some feel that the bill is a sell-out on the part of the Philippines. Some, on the other hand, fear that the bill might cause a “shooting war” with China.

But what is important is for us to really understand what the bill is about, especially now that the fears and the indignation has somehow blurred people’s thoughts and understanding of the issues surrounding it.

Read More »

Post

Détente in Asia?

In Cross-Strait Relations,International Relations,Japanese Politics,Politics,South China Sea on June 14, 2008 by The Nutbox

While European diplomats were having terrible headaches over the Irish’s rejection of the Treaty of Lisbon (which basically is a Xeroxed copy of the rejected EU Constitution), Friday the Thirteenth saw the spirit of détente spreading through Asia with the restoration of commercial flights between Taiwan and China and Japan’s partial lifting of economic sanctions on North Korea.

Not so long ago, tensions built up between Taipei and Beijing over Taiwanese President Chen Sui-ban’s emphasis on the creation of strong a Taiwanese identity and his well-known aspirations for an independent Taiwan.

Chen’s presidency sparked an important debate on Taiwan’s future: should the island strive for independence, or should it continue honoring its Chinese heritage and strive for re-unification with the mainland at some point?

Read More »

Post

Manila’s best options on the Spratlys dispute.

In International Relations,Philippine Politics,Politics,South China Sea,The ASEAN on March 15, 2008 by The Nutbox

Much has been said about the treasonous deal Gloria Arroyo forged with Beiijing and Hanoi. But only a few seems to be looking for the best way out of this imbroglio for the Philippines.

The agreement breached the Constitution, offered Philippine terittories for exploration by foreigners and destroyed the political solidarity of the ASEAN, which was the key to the region’s successes against Chinese provocations during the last decade. But now that these damages have been exposed, what steps should Manila take to clean the mess?

Read More »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 30 other followers